MondayApr23
Tuesday, 17 April 2012 13:20

Painful Aid

17 April 2012

Written by Nik Soni (first published on the Development Policy Blog

Has the donor world lost the plot? This is a question that most people I know who work in aid often ask themselves privately but few will raise publicly. Are the various contortions that those of us who work on the ground are forced to go through actually making the situation worse for people in developing countries or better?

It is true that the need for development assistance to help the most disadvantaged people is noble, sensible and smart. It is also true that more funds in this area would certainly help more people. But there is a growing concern amongst many practitioners in the field that those in charge of development at the highest institutional levels have simply lost touch with reality.

Like with the eighties obsession with MBAs coming in and telling experienced business hands how to run a business they knew nothing about nor had any background in - some would argue that the world of development has become bloated with highly qualified dreamers and that as a result the development agenda has lost focus and become hi-jacked by simply following one fad after another.

It is hardly surprising that around the world the tough financial times are asking many Governments’ Treasuries to question why funds are being placed in development especially when the development agencies themselves seem incapable of providing anything other than pithy statements. I highlight below just some short term fads we have seen here in the Pacific in the past few years.

Aid as an industry that operates like any other in the private sector

In the private sector you are accountable to yourself so you are able to make decisions that are not questioned. In aid you are accountable to a host of external parties and so cannot make decisions[1]. 

In the private sector if you mess up you pay, but by the same token you can rebuild. In aid somebody else pays and so there is no learning curve as the wrong person feels the consequences of your failure.

In Government it is usually better to focus on process and not product. This is not to say the end product is not important - it is. But if we accept that the process by which we achieve a good outcome is more important that simply being presented with an outcome then we should not only be targeting outcomes and outputs. This is what the original debate on “governance” was all about – improving process. But somehow we seem to think the Government is about selling something – it is not - it is about delivering a public service and that is very different to selling a product.

In the private sector you sell your outputs - so usually it is measurable, often tangible. You worry about outcome in terms of profitability and return to shareholder. In aid we are adopting this thinking and so there are some who think we should worry more about the return to the tax payer and not the return to recipient. But that is not what development should be about and by pretending to monitor output we move away from the correct mandate which is ultimately to alleviate poverty and not to focus on getting the greatest possible return to the Australian or New Zealand tax payer.

You cannot quantify the cost per unit of health or education and to do so is simply foolish. You can look at ways to deliver the same service cheaper and better but to do that you need to focus not on dreamed up targets – anybody can make up a random target – look at the MDGs. But few people seem have the nous to explain why we failed to get there in the first place. Simply setting more pointless targets may seem like a great day’s work for those in their lovely colour matched, air conditioned offices but it really is quite pointless to those who are perhaps trying to actually help a school in a remote village educate children.

Zero tolerance

Zero tolerance - a big buzz word in development today. Zero tolerance is a good concept. It means we don't aim to make errors. But it does not mean that errors will never occur and that any error no matter how small should be seen as indication of disaster. It does mean that there is a process by which errors are identified and action taken resulting, over time, in as few mistakes as possible. It does not mean there will never be any mistakes.

It can take the Australian Government years to deal with complex legal cases of fraud or mismanagement. In the developing world the fact that fraud exists is seen as a reason to begin Salem witch trials against civil servants and insist on parallel systems and lots of expatriate consultants to handle the money.

It is rare to see a donor look at what happens after the fraud has been discovered to see if there is a process and patiently wait for that process to occur. It is more normal to assume that any fraud is a sign of bad governance rather than see what the governance process is. Zero tolerance should not mean that there will never be fraud – if that was the case no agency in the Australian or New Zealand or any public body would ever receive funds as fraud happens – it is as simple as that. What matters are the processes in place to deal with it.

Misunderstanding and papering over important issues like gender, disability and climate change. These should not become or be treated as fads.

Climate change, disability and gender are important issues. This does not mean we add a paragraph in every report on gender and disability impacts or make sure that every funding application has the words ‘climate change’ in them. It does mean that we look at these challenges as discrete and work out how best to address them rather than insist everybody be aware of the problem and make pithy statements about them.

Right now we all know that to get funding you need to mention these words – I recently came across people doing a gender impact study on climate change. Not because they knew anything about the subject of gender – they were all climate change specialists – but because it was the only way to secure funds for their research.

This is a tragedy not only for the climate change research as lying is rarely a good idea but also for the gender research as it progresses little. The same is true for areas like disability.  I suspect disabled people don’t want pithy statements in reports that may one day result in ramp to a post office in a developing country with an AusAID badge on it – I suspect they do want to be able to show how they can contribute their skills to the challenges faced in many developing countries. But as long as we treat these issues like fashions – wearing them this season only because you look good by doing so – then we will never really come to grips with these issues.

Incentives

In aid we never allow spanner monkeys (who are usually grumpy old men and women soured from years in the field) any input into process as we are dominated by "big picture economists" who do not know the mechanics. It’s the difference between getting advice from a kid with an MBA and no practical experience and a seasoned mechanic on how to fix your car. In aid we loved the Masters in Development or PhD kids and discount the mechanics and front line people.

In the private sector if you do that you go out of business - in aid you cannot go out of business. And therein lies the dichotomy of trying to use business models for public spending.

In the private sector you either make a profit and survive or you make a loss and eventually go broke. In Government you can never go broke and there is no little loss from messing up.

As a result the incentive in Government is to cover up your losses – this is why no aid project is ever deemed a failure, this is also why donors almost never learn from their mistakes as they deny making them in the first place and it is also why they also are always chasing the next rainbow – as doing that is more likely to yield extra money than admitting you did something wrong and trying to fix it.

Return of the mechanics?

It is hardly surprising that around the world (including Australia) Ministries of Finances are questioning the increases in the aid budget. As long as donors continue to respond with fads, dreams and pithy statements you cannot be surprised when the reaction from Governments is to reconsider giving extra money. If aid agencies cannot show direction, understanding of their business, real understanding of the practical things that are needed to address a problem then I am afraid to say that the most likely outcome will be that eventually Governments around the world will renege on their aid funding pledges and they would be right to. It will be a disastrous but inevitable outcome caused by the fact there are few people heading aid agencies these days who know anything about the mechanics of government or poverty or aid. This fact is now painfully evident not just to seasoned “front line process mechanics” like myself but also many others. It is no wonder that public opinion and many civil servants are beginning to rebel against the generally held notion that all development spending is implicitly good.

If aid spending is to survive the current financial crisis those leading the aid agencies – be they multilateral or bi-lateral will have to start listening to those people trying to deliver services on the ground. If they don’t they may well find that both they and those trying to deliver services all lose.

Nik Soni is the Chairman of the Pacific Institute of Public Policy and a Research Associate of the Development Policy Centre

 


[1] This may be why many folk in development often dream about and try and behave like benign dictators. 

1 Comment

  • Comment Link Tuesday, 17 April 2012 16:37 posted by Lam Dang

    Excellent article. I wanted to say a lot of these things but never found the right words.

Leave a comment

Make sure you enter the (*) required information where indicated.
Basic HTML code is allowed.

Dancing_bear_-_party_in_the_salon.wmv vollhardt solutions emeli sande4sharedelly tran ha sextape prova da caixa economica federal de 2010 download gratis silkroad.edx.loader.v5_last.rar free pathology ebook download living without you mp3 download 4shared chapter 21 jay withgott heidi marcum mp4 movies mobilekm kardashan jay z videos Codoncode aligner silkroad.edx.loader.v5_last.rar Erick pokerist hack ipadhint word for jungle calldownload polymer clay book chapter 21 jay withgott heidi marcum professional asp net mvc 3 ebookee.. 4shared star academy 4 en 13804naruto mp3 4shared Prison.Break.1.x.08.El.viejo euro truck simuletor 1.3 say something drake driver sis 962lua 4shared k53s asus camera driver software downloaduna bionda sotto scorta ita torrent Erick nude kareena kapoor fucking simetry.molecular.and.group.theory.alan.vicent.rar free download principals of management ciambella in pdf free warrock premium code 2012traduzione testo don omar ft natti natashanudepinoymale Atargatis ppt on fiber reinforced soil amor prohibido - mana. Download 4shared gfrevenge videos allexissp1 windows 7windows 7 home premium oa greektajima dgml by pulse attach your securitydownload psim 90 full crack driver sis 962lua 4shared controladora ethernet 1969 2060 iso 2768 mk down load autodata.2011.torrent_[bookgod].rar marathi acterss nude imageissue_15_spoilt_babiespart3rar V.wie.Vendetta.cbr spiderman 4 megavideo ita possession de eric guirado universal cracker 2012sherlok homs 2 onlinetop eleven hack v47audit theory test bank ciambella in pdf fifa manager 12 total reality mod LODI Regolamento Locale di Igiene.pdf wikipedia shamanes crew torrent comic xxx madremediafire pop hits 2011? Ebook requiem por un campesino español Europe - Bag of Bones 2012 ppt on fiber reinforced soil pista de intentalo 3 ballfile explorer s6v5 2012 literature in english 1914 to the present paper-iv! Travel great britain download velamma episode 11 the affair [Met-Art] Maura A - Sweet Dream nada é por acaso kkm matematika kelas xii semester 2free download video hd3gpstripe girl EJEMPLO DE SRS [URL=http://smart4pc.info/cudbe-crack-serial-torrent-rapidshare-download.html]Download Cudbe with Serial Crack Keygen[/URL] young boys and grils sex vidoeswatch ma mere megavideosserial nero 11 platinum ita torrentred wap sex banzai ita toradora holy night mediafire Giganti-Mettete.Dei.Fiori.Nei.Vostri.Cannoni.zip xgirlsanimalsvideocom serial.agent.ransack.2010.[cook.book].7zip WoW-3.3.5.12213-to-3.3.5.12340-esES-downloader videos de menores cojiendo con papahigh voltage tattoo epub torrentpembahasan soal un tkj 2011 Mathematical_Methods__For_Students_of_Physics_and_Related_Fields theatre_of_war_3_keygen_crack campuran.beton.k.100.s.d.rar extabit photoshop cs5 elephormghettogaggersalcatel x080s driver for os x lion il.manuale.del.personal.trainer.nsca.pdf descargar ukash generator 2012 1-03_Cooler_Than_Me_ft._Big_Sean.mp3 Tera Patrick - My Plaything Tera Patrick (naughty b mom with son hot modegrooverindustrial roboticstorrent gamecube roms free download xxx indian home videoteori pembelajaran interaksionisme clé PronoFoot expert plus 4 2 0 14 8 accountingbase rar ammakodukudengulatacontroladora ethernet ^19691062 rhiannon motherless mp3 la sinesti pe magistrala gta 4 android apk download torrent downloader Beyond Borders - James Horner DUNE MKV TORRENT mom teen son indian sex storiesfree download prodad mercali for edius 6mandy moore i wanna be with you sheet music mortal kombat 1995 shameless s02e09 mkv wikipedia shamanes crew nong porn com webcam020 modern family streaming ita 2x06 fileserve krugova.zbirka.iz.matematike_[DVD-full].zip vdeo sma ngntot Europe - Bag of Bones 2012 free download ninja hattori games for pcbangladeshi 3gp fucking vediokelseylee723 asap rocky peso free mp3 download hell_s_kitchen_saison_2_vf_ddl.XVID.mkv! Epson adjprog starfront collision map hacksfast times chelsea free vdownloadfkk poland photo instrument v4,9 krack tablet pc ppt! Travel great britain hidden camera in wc handbook of adult and continuing education wirelesskeyview para nokia e5 nada é por acaso mp3mobipdf of engineering machines Bode.ghad.barjil.dhol usbxtafgui v31 download gratis [URL=http://smart4pc.info/cudbe-crack-serial-torrent-rapidshare-download.html]Download Cudbe with Serial Crack Keygen[/URL] 17. Janet Jackson feat. Nelly - Call On Me (Lil Jon Remix).incomplete tubu golre 3gp video downloadfumetto dragon ball z xxx WiiMC Channel Installer 1.9 Bel-Ami--2012- sherlockholmesgiocodiombre2011 torrentpro farm 1 torent haruna-yabuki 01-Sigueme_Manuel_Carrasco.mp3 rbd145descargar widgets para samsung s3850kingdom of amalur nude mod patch แอบถ ายxxx underground net Fedde Le Grand - So Much Love (Deniz Koyu Remix) (www.music.luigykent.org) 7 loader extreme edition medaifire! Download adele-someone like you.mp3... Un.Vampiro.Suelto.En.Brooklyn_[DVDRip][Spanish]_by_pepe58 crack no dvd sims 3 showtimehijo lo cacha a su mama durmiendopack for j10i2 Tower.Heist-Hindi-BRRip-Deadman-1 the big boss hindi WoW-3.3.5.12213-to-3.3.5.12340-esES-downloader? Solutions.advanced.students.book.audio.cds.workbook.part1.rar teacher sex tamilkaley cuoco desnuda follando skripsi.pengaruh.telepon.genggam.terhadap.prestasi.belajar-[bookgod].pdf marathi kadambari free downloadfreee sex shqip 2012saher malik sex battlefield play4free battlefunds generator v1 0 bus simultor 2012 letltsemesmerism techniquessaimin gakkyu game cg belami online jack harrer photoshoot video drive ac motor gun apps for samsung gts5230 up si answer sheet 2011 .pdf iso12216.free.download.torrent_b9932.zip solution manual numerical methods for engineers 6th edition christina perry thousand years avi sara jay andthomson tcw 690710forced gay mp4 porn InfoUpdate1SimulasiMakErotDewasa.txt Advanced.Archive.Password.Recovery.Pro.v4.0.by_Axl_jp.rar asp.net cours pdf little girlsex dadpedo age 13yo xxxmalayalam kambi phone chatgirls get diapers for bad grades black tranny whackers angeline vignard Strategic Link Building talking cat jad software 3d instructor 2.2.4 full crack fruit ninja frenzy lg kp500 jar animal sec knot tied girls creswell Educational research touchstone 2 workbook resuelto mediafire gsm technology pdf 2 0 14 8 accountingbase rar melanie laurent sexbajar discografia completa gino vanelli concrete angel gareth bajar gratis manual fiat siena 2000. Microsoft_windows_xp_sp3_corporate_student_edition_may_2011_-_dudeuk_[tenebra].part1 sara paretsky downloaddetonado pokemon light platinum completo gbaarturia v collection mac audescargar hack 1 hit kill metin2 easy cd da extractor 2011 ultimate Stronghold crusader italiano discretetime control systemstop eleven hack generator file passwordporno para celular descargar gratis rta ford mondeo 2 5 v6 gratuit pdf manu chao proxima estacion esperanza lado b saouth india hot aunty sexbmw e30 reparaturhandbuch pdfbilo jednom u americi sa prevodom download music video super junior opera era mia sorella torrentea sports cricket play for free dil ye bekarar kyun hai mp3 4shared http://ywarxejibhys.com/... total excel converter 3 0 taringa sexy girls model nong porn com webcam020 call girls mobile number in baroda adele 2010 songs mp3 cscs pdfgrupe sexo graph theory narsingh pokemon 14 n0574 spss statistics 20 keygen macseriales mcafee gratisvirtually jennharga trainer eldasinazuma eleven 2 ndsmeet and fuck up to 2012 nhibernate in .net pdf for beginners free download binksetmixbins volume20latest pashto nude dance. Abg yang baru dientot taare zameen par myegy pelicula paramo descargar gratis juegos para cel nokia c3kim kardashian full sextape part 2candydoll rarget bebuzz license key free. Descargar_gratis_alba_ca_zapada_an_romana.320kbps.wma? C0024_24 Vuelven.los.mejores.1994 unnam1080p_a_v_i_torrent_Win32.sitx free download video bokep terbarustima10 tfm crackimagenes porno para moviles 320x240 handbook of adult and continuing education. Kayden-kross-the8thday1.mkv chapali.height.nepali.movies-full.iso prabhas eswar movie asset pricing pennacchi download Microsoft.Windows.7.Enterprise.x64.SP1.Integrated.March.2012-BIE.part1.rar the false princess e book free download fake windows 7apk.